A contract is a contract.

Status
Not open for further replies.

La Li Lu Le Lo

Veteran
May 29, 2010
7,368
2,666
http://www.foxnews.c...rican-airlines/

He’s the man who flew too much.

Steve Rothstein bought a golden ticket from American Airlines in 1987 — granting him a lifetime of unlimited travel.

He clocked more than 10 million miles and 10,000 flights. He used his power to fly hopeless strangers home, a friend to the Louvre, and a priest to Rome to meet the pope. He hopped planes to other cities just for a baseball game or a sandwich.

" became a hero at the airline," Rothstein, 61, a Manhattan investment banker, told The Post. "I could just show up and get a seat."

But in 2008, AA accused him of fraud and snatched his bottomless boarding pass.

American is reviewing its AAirpass program to find ways to terminate some of the 66 high-flying contracts that are costing the company millions of dollars a year.

Rothstein, then living in Chicago, bought his AAirpass for $250,000, plus a companion ticket for $150,000 more.

He traveled 18 times in July 2004 alone, jetting to Nova Scotia, Maine, London, Los Angeles and Denver.

He booked flights under fake names such as "Bag Rothstein" if he didn’t know who his companion would be — a practice that the airline later used to accuse him of fraud.

Because of the AAirpass, his daughter went to boarding school in Switzerland. He took his son to dozens of nationwide sporting events including the Yankees-Mets Subway Series.

Some days he flew to Providence, RI, home of his alma mater, Brown University, just for a baloney-and-Swiss-cheese melt from a place called Geoff's.

Still, the charmed traveler paid his fortune forward.

He gave away all of his 14 million air miles. If a stranded traveler was crying — such as one woman desperately trying to return to Bronxville, NY, because her children didn’t have a baby sitter — he’d offer her his companion seat.

"I felt those random acts of kindness were exactly the sorts of things that we're meant to do as people," he said.

It was on another goodwill trip that Rothstein was ultimately dethroned, and he had no idea it was coming.

On Dec. 13, 2008, he checked in at Chicago O’Hare International Airport with a friend, a policeman hoping to return to his native Bosnia.

An AA employee gave him a letter saying his pass had been terminated due to fraudulent activity.

He went home in shock and didn’t leave bed for days.

"I feel betrayed," Rothstein said, adding that he helped sell AAirpasses to firms and spoke at the carrier's events. "They took away my hobby and my life. They essentially destroyed my persona."

Rothstein filed a lawsuit and a federal judge in Illinois ruled against him for booking under phony names. The case is now being appealed.

"Our country is almost captive to big companies who have incredible power to do whatever they want to do," said Rothstein, who moved to New York in 2009. "It's hard to fight them."

But that’s just what he’s doing to get his beloved AAirpass back.

“They signed a contract,” he said, “and a contract’s a contract.”

End of Article

A contract is a contract indeed but AMR does not honor contracts.
 
This is one of those stories where we'll probably never know the truth but have to settle for "he said, she said". The first article I saw about said that this guy was, among other things not allowed by the terms of his "golden ticket", selling award tickets and booking seats in fake names then cancelling at the last minute so that a seat would be available for his "companion" to use.

So is this guy shedding tears because he got caught or because he did nothing wrong but is wrongly accused?

Jim
 
A court in Illinois has already upheld AA's actions against Rothstein as being within their rights.

Bartering has always been against the rules for AAdvantage as long as I've been a member (over 20 years) but it's possible that wasn't part of the original AAirpass contracts because nobody expected someone to be gaming the system.

Buying the companion AAirpass was on my "if I win the lottery tomorrow" list for a while.

Now, I'm not quite so sure it's a wise investment.
 
A court in Illinois has already upheld AA's actions against Rothstein as being within their rights.

Bartering has always been against the rules for AAdvantage as long as I've been a member (over 20 years) but it's possible that wasn't part of the original AAirpass contracts because nobody expected someone to be gaming the system.

Buying the companion AAirpass was on my "if I win the lottery tomorrow" list for a while.

Now, I'm not quite so sure it's a wise investment.

The Illinois court may have held the company's position, however the court of the business world may frown?
 
Unlikely. There are supposedly only about 50 lifetime unlimited AAirpasses still in circulation, and most were bought by individuals 10 to 20 years ago.
 
So what is the real problem?

50 lifetime passes will run out over a short period of time. I guess M&R should voted yes to offset these passes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.