I think to answer your question, ASAP has morphed from being a tool used to learn from past mistakes into a "get out of jail free card".The FAA I believe, wants to steer that ship back to where it was intended. If you flagrantly miss several steps of a manual reference, or exhibit reckless behavior, it's not going to save you in the future.
The company on the other hand, (I've heard that US never participated in ASAP) hates ASAP, and are trying to find reckless behavior in EVERY incident. JC and MEAA hearings are an everyday occurrence in my station. I've also heard that the PPC form of discipline is out the window and some form of point system is now in place. The dollar amount of damage you cause determines the severity of your punishment.