Don Carty delays another 10-K Filing with SEC

eolesen

Veteran
Jul 23, 2003
15,988
9,428
As background, the audit committee is typically made up entirely of outside directors, which is the case with Dell.

What's unsaid in all this is that Carty was chair of the audit committee during 2005 and 2006, which is when most of the "misconduct" probably took place.

Dell Digs Up the Dirt
By Alexei Oreskovic
TheStreet.com Senior Writer
3/30/2007 9:49 AM EDT

URL: http://www.thestreet.com/newsanalysis/tech...e/10347570.html

Updated from March 29

Dell (DELL) said it has discovered evidence of misconduct and a number of accounting errors -- the company's most serious admission about its bookkeeping practices that triggered an investigation by the Securities and Exchange Commission.

The computer giant also will not be able to file its annual report on time because of the investigation, and will miss the April 18 extension date to file the 10-K report. Dell is already delinquent in filing its quarterly report for the third quarter of fiscal 2007.

The delinquencies have put Dell at risk of being delisted from the Nasdaq, although the exchange has stayed action to delist the stock pending a full review by a Nasdaq special council.

Shares of Dell dropped more than 6% after the previous close but were lately down 1.5% to $23.03 Friday morning.

Thursday's announcement is the latest sign of trouble at Dell, which has seen sales stall in the past year due to a mixture of operational stumbles and stronger competition from Hewlett-Packard (HPQ) . Dell's stock is down 23% in the past 12 months.

Earlier this year, founder Michael Dell returned to the CEO post, replacing Kevin Rollins, in the hopes of rejuvenate the company. But Thursday's revelation about misconduct and deficiencies in the financial control environment signal that the accounting investigation may complicate the turnaround plan.

"As we move toward the conclusion of our investigation, we are committing the time and resources required to ensure a thorough and comprehensive review and resolution of all identified issues and the implementation of appropriate remedial measures," said Dell director Thomas Luce, who chairs the company's audit committee.

Dell said it was still trying to determine whether the accounting errors will require restatements of past financial reports, and whether the control deficiencies represent a material weakness in Dell's internal controls over financial reporting.

Dell has been vague about exactly what the accounting investigation involves. In previous statements, Dell has said the investigations are examining certain accounting and financial matters, including issues related to reserves and other balance-sheet items that may affect its past financial results.

In December, Dell CFO James Schneider resigned from the company and was replaced by Donald Carty, the former CEO of American Airlines parent AMR (DELL) .
 
It sounds like the screw up was already there before Carty arrived, but he may have a hand in screwing up how to go about fixing or handling the screw up.

One screw up leads to another and then a snowball is rolling.
 
Yes, the other CFO probably screwed up, but as head of the audit committee, Carty signed off on Rollins' work.

In the AMT world, who's accountable for a screw-up: the one who actually did the work, or the one who checked the work and signed off the logbook?
 
It sounds like the screw up was already there before Carty arrived, but he may have a hand in screwing up how to go about fixing or handling the screw up.

One screw up leads to another and then a snowball is rolling.

How fun would that be, watching Don screw up at Dell.
 
Well at one point he must have put up with it. Otherwise Dell would not be having the problems it has curretnly.
Offically, Michael Dell only been back at CEO for 2 months, after taking a few years off. Although I'm sure it's safe to say that he had some say in a company with his name on it.
 
Carty has been a member of the board at Dell for a few years. It seems Michael Dell asked him to take the CFO job after they realized there were problems. Being chair of the audit committee might seem to suggest that he should/could have found problems earlier, but the board isn't typically involved in the day to day ops where issues of this nature occur. It seems quite simply, Dell is trying to fix the problems before they tear down the company he built and that bears his name...
 

Latest posts