Guys, a special thanks to all of you who helped me. I will explain how this happened, because some of you may be interested. It was mostly my fault... US was right, I was wrong.
A super special thank you to Ms. Walker from "Executive Offices" - she was incredible. She figured everything out and even called me three times today while she was working on it. This was truly customer service at it's best.
Ok, so there is a short version of this story, and a long version... So the shortened version of the story is...
A) It was all my fault.
B ) Ms. Walker at US Airways Executive Offices was incredible, and provided amazing customer care.
C ) If the website was a little bit easier to use, and had more information about previous flights, and showed flights that were booked via the phone, I wouldn't have had to ask for help.
Now for the long version, if anyone is interested...
Ok, so here is what happened. The whole senario was basically all my fault, but I would have been able to figure it out on my own if the "res system" was a bit better. Bank of America also put the wrong description on my statement.
An important piece to remember for this incident is... When you do a phone reservation with US Airways, for whatever reason, the itinerary does not show up online under your Divident Miles account.
Ok, so back to step one. I booked a round trip for me and another person for June 11 - June 12 via the Chairmans desk. This round trip was from AVP/PHL PHL/ORD. We both took the AVP/PHL leg. PHL/ORD was delayed by 4 hours. I hopped on Southwest. When I got to MDW, I called US and explained that I skipped a leg, but to please protect my reservation because I really was in Chicago, and I needed to get home tomorrow. Ok... that was done. So...
Now its June 12, and I'm getting ready to return home. I checked the flight status, and it was now delayed 2 hours. I had not yet gone to the airport. I checked the board at the hotel for Southwest, and they were not delayed. I bought the Southwest ticket 1 hour before the flight, via phone, and went to MDW. I called US, and told them again, that the flight I was on was delayed, and I just want to get home, so I'm jumping on Southwest. I asked if they would protect my PHL/AVP even though I was jumping again. They said they would, as long as I didnt mind that I had non refundables. I totally didnt care about a refund, I just wanted to get back home. (The delays were weather, and ORD blows. Once ORD backs up, forget it).
I also had award tickets for AVP/PHL roundtrip on June 13.
So my statement comes, and it says this...
6/12 US Airways
AVP/PHL Roundtrip $636.00
6/12 US Airways
AVP/PHL Roundtrip $636.00
I immediately think that it is because I was charged for the 6/13 award ticket, since that was the only time I flew AVP/PHL roundtrip. It turns out, since i never took the ORD flight, Bank of America used AVP/PHL Roundtrip as the descriptor. If it has said AVP/ORD Roundtrip, I would have known this is what it was.
So before I started blaming US for messing up my charge, I spent about an hour trying to figure out if this was somehow my fault (I am used to it usually being my fault, so I really try to give others the benefit of the doubt). Since phone reservations don't show up online in your Dividend Miles account, I totally forgot that I had even went to ORD. I had printed out my past trips, and the ORD tickets never showed up there, because I did a phone reservation... I just assumed I was billed for the AVP/PHL award.
I know, you're saying, how could you not remember? It was a month ago, and I fly every week. I really didnt even remember going to ORD, but when Ms. Walker asked me - "Did you do some kind of roundtrip to ORD and then not take certain legs", I was like, CRAP, yes...
So there you have it.
Thank you all again, for those of you who PM'd me and offered advice.
I really appreciate everything...