In those situations, the business
case does not support the additional cost and operational impact of granting more requests than are necessary
One positive note about the delays in granting the VBRs is that it shows that the company is being cautious about letting people, who it will be hard to replace, go.
If there were lots of people out there who were willing -and able- to do our jobs for less you would think that the company would jump at the opportunity to let topped out workers go-but they arent, because there isnt.
And thats good for us, because if they cant replace us then we should not settle for anything but full restoration-plus.
I think that they were shocked at how fast they burnt through the recall list, and a few of those that actually returned promptly put in for the VBR.
If they really felt they were paying us too much then they would jump at the opportunity to dump as many topped out workers as possible. If they could replace topped out workers who are at just over $30/hr with six weeks vacation and in the process of burning off their sick banks (which would result in around 4 or more weeks of paid time off in addition to vacation), with workers making half as much with only 5 paid days off a year and no sick time it would pay for the VBRs and even the $12500 or whatever they are offering in less than a year. Then they would be saving even more every year after that.
Look around at the people you work with. Do you see anyone under 20? Under 25? How many are under 30? How many kids out there do you think want to come into this industry when they can sell their skills elsewhere? Not many. And from a negotiations standpoint, thats good news for us.
So dont let all the doom and gloom put out by the media, the airlines and the International worry you. The airline industry is not just serving people who want to go on vacation, its more like a utility than a luxury, a vital part of the economy, the planes must fly and if we all walked they would have to bring us back because there arent enough people out there with the skills required to replace us.