Windfall

[skyflyr69]

Your school aged child mistakenly receives an A while doing B work. Would you expect little Johnny to keep that windfall A grade?

😱

 

[wings396]

And this has what to do with the Aviation indusrty???? :blink:

 

[LCC_#1]

And this has what to do with the Aviation indusrty???? :blink:

I think the word "WINDFALL" says it all.

2 choices moderators.

1. Let the fighting begin. I'll give it 5 posts.
2. Close it before it even starts.

 

[aquagreen73s]

Your school aged child mistakenly receives an A while doing B work. Would you expect little Johnny to keep that windfall A grade?

😱

Ok, I'll bite. It's a simple matter of reviewing the record and determing whether the assigned grade was correct. If so, then the grade stands. Some jealous runts might THINK that Johnny should have gotten a B, but what a jealous runt thinks and what is objectively reasonable are two different things.

 

[Richard]

Ok, I'll bite. It's a simple matter of reviewing the record and determing whether the assigned grade was correct. If so, then the grade stands. Some jealous runts might THINK that Johnny should have gotten a B, but what a jealous runt thinks and what is objectively reasonable are two different things . . .

This is basically an ethics question related to the ALPA issue. Other than that it has nothing to do with US Airways or aviation in general.

I will let the members speak. Here are the choices:

1. Close it

2. Let's see where it goes here

3. Move to water cooler and watch it.


Technically it is off base because it is not directly related to aviation, PLUS it is a discussion of ethics relating to ALPA, which already has its threads for the week.

BUT as I said, we will keep an open mind.....so vote away.

 

[LCC_#1]

This is basically an ethics question related to the ALPA issue. Other than that it has nothing to do with US Airways or aviation in general.

I will let the members speak. Here are the choices:

1. Close it

2. Let's see where it goes here

3. Move to water cooler and watch it.
Technically it is off base because it is not directly related to aviation, PLUS it is a discussion of ethics relating to ALPA, which already has its threads for the week.

BUT as I said, we will keep an open mind.....so vote away.

I vote #3. They love a good fight over there.

 

[aquagreen73s]

This is basically an ethics question related to the ALPA issue. Other than that it has nothing to do with US Airways or aviation in general.

I will let the members speak. Here are the choices:

1. Close it

2. Let's see where it goes here

3. Move to water cooler and watch it.
Technically it is off base because it is not directly related to aviation, PLUS it is a discussion of ethics relating to ALPA, which already has its threads for the week.

BUT as I said, we will keep an open mind.....so vote away.

My vote is to not only close it, but obliterate it. It's merely another stupid thread that wishes to vent frustrations when the time for the anger stage has long passed. It's now high time for acceptance and to just move on. I regret succumbing to the temptation to go there. My apologies.

 

[luvthe9]

My vote is to not only close it, but obliterate it. It's merely another stupid thread that wishes to vent frustrations when the time for the anger stage has long passed. It's now high time for acceptance and to just move on. I regret succumbing to the temptation to go there. My apologies.

That's funny you giving an apoolgy, your one of the biggest pot stirrers Go have a beer with DOUG!!

 

[wench1]

#2.

 

[exB717Flyer]

Your school aged child mistakenly receives an A while doing B work. Would you expect little Johnny to keep that windfall A grade?

Yes. Most teachers would agree as well.

Regarding binding arbitration: the arbitrator decides what constitutes a windfall. Nicolau didn't make a mistake; he made a decision. It may be your opinion that there is a windfall but legally there is not.

 

[bigbusboy]

Or....

4. Move it over to the ALPA thread

 

[LCC_#1]

Or....

4. Move it over to the ALPA thread

It only took 10 threads. I'm pulling up a chair. Pass the popcorn! 😛

 

[AWA320]

This is basically an ethics question related to the ALPA issue. Other than that it has nothing to do with US Airways or aviation in general.

I will let the members speak. Here are the choices:

1. Close it

2. Let's see where it goes here

3. Move to water cooler and watch it.
Technically it is off base because it is not directly related to aviation, PLUS it is a discussion of ethics relating to ALPA, which already has its threads for the week.

BUT as I said, we will keep an open mind.....so vote away.

Close this crap down!!!

 

[EastUS]

Close this crap down!!!

Aquagreen: "My vote is to not only close it, but obliterate it. "

I'll vote "2. Let's see where it goes here". No big decision there....all the squirming's coming from one side, as this approaches addressing some notions of actual morality Large popcorn/Coke pls.

PS: Anything, book/thread or otherwise, that immediately sets both AWA320 and Aquagreen out with torches to stack and burn before it's read by anyone..well..ya' gotta' love that 😉

 

[LCC_#1]

Large popcorn/Coke pls.

Super size that for you, sir?