The point regarding Midwest is as usual missed. It's the ATTITUDE of the Company and it's employees towards customers that makes the difference.
For years and years HP had/has the mentality of doing things "Good Enough". In that respect they are like my 14 year old Timmy who does just enough homework and class work to get a C and pass the class. He has no thoughts of ever striving to be the best at anything he does, whether it be school work or chores around the house. Just does enough not to get reamed out by Mom or I.
My older stepson Will is not nearly as bright and busts his ever loving assets and for the first time he made Principal's List and we framed the letter.
It occurred to me that certain airlines are a lot like my step kids. Will busts his butt and comes up a winner. Think of him as WN or CO
While Timmy is US Airways personified. Could just blow WN and CO away but just muddles along & is content with being "good Enough".
This is why, while the numbers are a pleasant surprise, I still fear for their long term viability as those at the top want to play Merger Mania which is much more sexy then Running an Airline 101 is.
Uh, no, Timmy is not US Airways personified, he is a cheap prop you are using to justify something that won't be. What is good enough today, is to make money and stay in business. US employees could bust their butts, but then, the entitlement union goons would complain about it.
How many full service airlines have we seen go bust in the last 20 years? Regent, Legend, MGM Grand, McClain, Air One, and more. We saw Alaska drop their high quality service and same for Midwest. As I said, I'd love it to be 30 years ago and get a nice free meal on a PHX-LAX flight, but that ain't happening, and bemoaning that loss won't bring it back. Passengers will, by an overwhelming majority choose the cheapest flight. Even if it means just a few bucks difference. That is the market. I love to flight in First Class, its swell, especially trans atlantic or trans pacific, but..... this is a tough economy, and what's a few hours. That is the mentality of the majority of fliers. Sorry you aren't pampered like you want, but, that's life. And, if you find a better carrier, go fly there, give up on US. Because things change, you can whine about them, but you aren't gonna change them. To do so is a monumental waste of time.