Carl Guardino usually comes across as an amenable, mild-mannered Silicon Valley executive. But not on Monday. Not when he watched President Obama promising to end overseas tax breaks for U.S. companies that "create a job in Bangalore, India, (rather than) one in Buffalo, N.Y." Guardino, CEO of the Silicon Valley Leadership Group, angrily described Obama's language as "not only discouraging, but divisive." The president's implication that companies such as Cisco Systems and Hewlett-Packard merely "ship jobs overseas," and are being rewarded in the bargain, came as a shock to Guardino, who otherwise described the president as "brilliant and respected by so many in the tech sector who are counting on the administration as their ally."
"It's a bad idea from the word go," said Sarin, who has consulted with the Internal Revenue Service and with Fortune 100 companies on international tax issues. "Increasing these taxes will reduce after-tax profits, which will reduce incentives. Right now, the administration should be helping Silicon Valley maintain its competitive edge, not making it less so. I hope saner minds will prevail."
Sang Kim, an international tax attorney at DLA Piper in East Palo Alto, decried Obama's Bangalore-Buffalo reference as "patently unfair and false." While he said the proposals were enticing, given the administration's drive to stimulate the domestic economy and raise more tax revenue, he warned of unintended consequences, including the possibility that more, not fewer, jobs could be shipped overseas. "Let's hope everyone thinks this through," he said.
