jimcfs
Veteran
First off, I agree that the "we were almost killed" reaction may be a bit over the top. I'm sure I'd be unnerved if an engine had to be shut down in-flight, even knowing that an aircraft is designed to fly safely on one engine. Having been involved with the old East "Flex Alert" system and getting notified everytime there was any sort of incident, there are certainly worse things.
SS255 brings up a good question, though: Wonder how the customers were handled?
As someone who has had an experience similar to this flight, let me relate my experience.
It was back in '98 IIRC (so CCY-based US). I was flying back from LAS in November on a LAS-PIT 737 redeye. We were all settled in when all the lights suddenly came on, and the guys up front tell us they had an oil light come on the right engine. So, rather than take any chances, they shut it down, requested emergency clearance to land in DEN. We were now at 10,000 and 30 miles out... would the FA's please ready the cabin for landing. (No emergency used in that request IIRC.) So, everyone was very silent. I knew we could fly/land on one engine, but many aboard didn't. So I did tell the people seated around me we were probably alright. I did say a prayer, just in case. Landing was normal and uneventful.
Once on the ground however, there were no US personnel to meet us, as they had left about a few hours before. (This was about 3AM Mountain Time.) So, we were told the tower had notified the station manager, and assistance was on the way... but they also had to call in security as the terminal at the new DIA wasn't secure for passengers to arrive at that time of the morning. We waited on the plane for a good 60-90 minutes before we pulled into a gate and were able to get out. Rather than wait for someone to rebook me, I called the Priority Gold line (I don't think the Preferreds were out yet) and got an agent to rebook me on the 10AM DEN-PIT flight (upgraded to F) and an updated connection (RDU I think, I don't remember that part). I had a lot of time to kill, but at that time the AA alliance was still around, so I was able to get into the AA club and relax once it opened about 6.
The pax on the flight accepted the situation as the crew kept us fully informed. We also knew it was the middle of the night, so once I was rebooked, I did recommend others to call and get rebooked instead of waiting in line with one agent working... IIRC I even passed the pay phone off to others once the rep knew our situation. There was nothing open in the terminal, but I don't recall anyone complaining about anything... it was a redeye anyway. We all just lost a little bit of sleep and got to our final destinations a little bit late. The situation was handled the best it could have... no complaints from me there.
They did fix the aircraft and it left shortly before my rescheduled flight left for PIT. I, however, had an issue about stepping back on that plane, so I kept my rebooked later flight.