No skin off my nose which union you pick, and no, I'm not telling you that you shouldn't be able to pick your own union.
My question is why have the mechanics suffered for nearly 50 years under such a crappy union and yet failed to form their own union, like the APA, that's all.
Sure the APA has a President - he's a captain for AA. Delle, on the other hand, has spent his lifetime cultivating a union without any members, and now that times are really bad, the desperate are flocking (slowly) to his brand of tonic.
AMFA looks a lot like a proprietary concern, not a labor union. Just because Delle was once a mechanic doesn't mean his union is any different from the busdriver's union.
On the early opener: We all know that an agreement to negotiate is an agreement without any real meaning, right?
Of course the agreement COULD be amended by agreement in 2006-08, but let's all be honest here - there's no way in hell AA will relent on the concessions prior to the expiration of the initial term. If anything, AA will probably come back, hat in hand, once US goes under and UAL extracts more money from its employees in its futile bid to stay alive.
Best of luck to you whichever union represents you.