I may be in the minority, but I don't think that representation and productivity are mutually exclusive.
With CVG, I think it's win-win; you eliminate duplication-and a 3rd party- while increasing the productivity of the remaining workforce, thus lowering over all costs (or at least off setting fixed costs somewhat.). While I'm diametrically opposed to Ready Reserve, that's a thought for another day. Hopefully, in the future that can be resolved as well, as I fully believe that "regular" employees have a more vested interest in the long term success of a company, and offer a larger return on the company's investment in them.
For employees, that may mean raising the performance bar somewhat, but it all starts with the hiring process; a good package attracts good workers. From there, a more rigorous application of the probationary review is required. I feel that these are two areas where both the union and company can work together. 'Course that means putting egos aside, but it's definitely doable-and needs to be done. I can only speak for myself, but I have no interest in my crew being populated with people that can barely fog a mirror, are glued to their iPhone the whole shift, or are constantly on Travelnet looking for their next flight.
Bottom line: I've said it before, but it bears repeating- If you want to be treated like a professional, you must act like a professional.
Back to insourcing: If DL means what they say, then it's time for more action. What now needs to happen at a minimum is the same thing at the handful of line stations where a similar situation to CVG continues to exist. All along, we have heard the "we can't do anything until representation is resolved." CVG just threw that argument out the window. There is no reason to continue to maintain duplicate workforces in these stations; especially if the M/L staff can absorb the work with the existing compliment. Another thing I personally would like to see is the return of cross utilization in the smaller PMDL cities where DL staffs M/L above wing, but farms out below wing work (these were called "4 hour rule" cities at NW).
As for insourcing, I'm all for it, mostly for the same reasons already discussed. I'd also like to see more handling contracts wherever possible. Again, these are all things that labor & the company can-and should- work on together if egos are put aside, and an air of mutual respect reigns.