but if you vote no and do get rid of the twu/iam association then you would become at will employees
True. And for 90% they have nothing to really worry about since they are already way below market rate. But the alternative is to leave the structures intact that have brought them to the bottom of the industry, below those of even "at will" workers. The guys are desperate for change, any change.
If they (the TWU/IAM) want to save this they have to make changes in the structures they are telling the members they should keep. For the TWU side they need to fire the appointed people, put them back at the wages they said everyone else should be happy with and allow the elected Presidents choose who will be the spokesman and chairman of their groups.
FED EX, Delta and Jet Blue all are non-union and all those mechanics are much better compensated than either US or AA.
This could just be another plug for the IBT. Nobody trusts this management enough to want to go non-union but nobody is happy with either the IAM or TWU, offering to keep them both in place pleases nobody except those drawing a paycheck from those two useless organizations. Lets face it, what does the TWU, IAM and IBT all have in common? They hate AMFA, so much so they wont even acknowledge that they are raiding at AA. They know if AMFA gets in at AA they will prevail against the IAM, and then AMFA would have the money to make an industry wide push, and they would likely prevail because conditions are not such that another NWA scenario could be played out. By offering what they know is unacceptable, two losers with no changes, and saying they are doing this to fend off the IBT (not AMFA), what would a dissatisfied member of either union be likely to do? Sign a card from the group thats trying to oust the Union that they are dissatisfied with! Thats why they dont even mention AMFA despite the fact that most believe that AMFA is closer to filing than the IBT. So the best thing for a dissatisfied member who doesnt want to be manipulated by any of these groups who have not been good for the profession to do would clearly be to fill out an AMFA card and screw them all!!