What's new

AA overreached

After reading the Judge's ruling, I would temper the celebration.

AA only has to tweak two items, and the Judge will grant AA's request.

You might be correct but we see in two weeks. The point is a craft, democratic union said no to an anti-labor management team while our industrial, undemocratic union said to vote yes because the judge would NOT do to us what he just did to the pilots. For that I salute the APA and have further contempt for the twu and yes voting AMTs.
 
"AMR Corp. (AAMRQ)’s American Airlines was denied approval from a U.S. bankruptcy judge to throw out its existing pilot contract and impose cost reductions needed to restructure after workers refused to accept concessions.

The airline didn’t make the case that its labor proposal for the pilots was necessary for its reorganization, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Sean Lane said in a decision filed today. He said that the airline could try again to persuade him otherwise. The ruling came one week after the union rejected a sweetened offer that would have eliminated furloughs and given the Allied Pilots Association a 13.5 percent stake in AMR after it emerged from court protection.

“The court concludes that American’s proposed changes to furlough and codesharing have not been justified,” Lane said in his opinion. “Given the significance of these two provisions collectively to American’s proposal, the court finds that American has not shown that the proposal is necessary as required...” http://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-08-15/american-denied-court-approval-to-toss-pilot-contract
 
I'm not a proud TWU member. Tulsa and the International had lead us to a total failure. Surrender before the fight even started. Thank to all yes voters we are in this hole now. Is there is any hope with the me too clause?
 
Bob,

Major disagree. Pay is lower than DAL/SWA and now UAL. Some areas may have been closer and paid more than LCC, but those are low for other others. For the job of a network legacy, APA pilots will shortly be paid the least.
Holidays? WT# are those? WE DON'T GET A SINGLE ONE. In fact we do even the most ridiculous training on every day of the year without a dime extra including Xmas day.
Vacation? Paid less and with less accrual than most other carriers. In fact, AA's vacation can be described as worst in the industry, especially anyone with less than 21 years. only those few with 30 years have a better deal than others.
Sick time? Again compares on the lower end of all airlines. The 1113 was even more disgusting.

The only things that we were out of line with comparisons were bidding and retirement. The new PBS system will take take of those productivity isses and the retirement was whacked. After that, we are well in line in any cost comparisons with all airlines, except USAir which has it's own reasons for that pay level.

Now you go and compare your groups costs against other airlines. Let me know what you find out for yourself and other AA employee groups. I don't like what happened in the airline world regarding things like overhaul and ramp workers, it is what it is.

Our pay is 20% less than DAL and UAL, around 50% less than SWA. How far are you below those carriers "all in".

Among pilots who has Paid Holidays? Among our peer group we get much, much less than half the Holiday pay. FAs dont get holiday pay either, my guess is that you typically do not report to work five days a week 50 weeks a year and the odds that the holiday falls on your day off are much higher and that once you pass the 50% mark on the seniority list you can bid all the holidays off you want. Therefore Holiday pay probably was not much of a priority for flight crews, except in 2000 when flight crews got a bonus if they showed up on New Years-we didnt.

Vacation, we have the worst accrual in the industry at all years, the longer you are here the worse it gets. For the first five years we only get 5 vacation days per year, how many do you get? For Holidays we get paid 4 hours extra for eight hours worked, so it works out to 2 and a half extra days pay for the year if worked. So for the first 5 years our total paid time off equals seven and a half days pay. Would it be fair to say that your total vacation time is more than our Vacation and holiday time combined?

Sick time, we get 5 days while most get either 10 or 12.

I've read your contract, have you read ours?

I'm ecstatic that the Judge ruled against the company, I'm just saying that we had a better arguement against abrogation than the pilots did. We went into this at the very bottom of the industry, we were "out of line" as far as pay, benefits and work rules but not above the line, we were and are below the line and going even lower. The only things the company could point to was the pension and retiree medical which we had agreed to give up. They had nothing to make their case that the terms they had in place were onerous.

We were sold out by the TWU and their "experts" once again.
 
After reading the Judge's ruling, I would temper the celebration.

AA only has to tweak two items, and the Judge will grant AA's request.

It's not that easy. I'm not saying that that is impossible, but that is one of many outcomes. Even if that does happen, then we branch out into about a dozen more what-if scenarios. I am hearing that there are a lot of things going on behind the scenes right now - not only with the company but with the UCC.

For those of you offering us good wishes, thank you.
 
I'm very proud of the Allied Pilots and their guts to take on the AA management.

The APA has won a major battle but still fighting the war.
Full Throttle Ahead!!!
And where are the "guts" from the mechanics representatives
 
It's not that easy. I'm not saying that that is impossible, but that is one of many outcomes. Even if that does happen, then we branch out into about a dozen more what-if scenarios. I am hearing that there are a lot of things going on behind the scenes right now - not only with the company but with the UCC.

For those of you offering us good wishes, thank you.

Count me as one of them. I just wish we were ther with you, from the line and AFW I think I can say we are in Spirit and will support you guys. As far as I'm concerned we are having terms imposed on us, just not by the Judge.
 
Hopefully our FAs are changing their APFA recommend “yes” vote to "no" as we speak.
I will change my vote, if you can tell me what item the judge will think the company is overreaching on compared to the other airlines.
 
The TWU was not even in the fight, the International and their point men of the round table folded before the games began.

Great showing of power and the AFL/CIO affiliation. It will be impossiblefor the TWU to organize anyone after this debacle!

Hey TWU, maybe you should have listened to the line Presidents they had better insight than our International leaders and the experts.


thanks to all for "fighting like hell"

We really are the weakest leading industry concessionary union!
 
It's not that easy. I'm not saying that that is impossible, but that is one of many outcomes. Even if that does happen, then we branch out into about a dozen more what-if scenarios. I am hearing that there are a lot of things going on behind the scenes right now - not only with the company but with the UCC.

For those of you offering us good wishes, thank you.

There is a point when inept management and concessions that are too far reaching are unacceptable.

The Pilots of the APA have proven that our AA Management is like no other.

Going into to Bankruptcy Court seeking to compete is one thing, going into the courts seeking far reaching concessions trying to gain a $3 billion cost advantage over you competition, because you think you can is obviously not allowed.

The TWU "experts" and the APFA "experts" have also been proven just as inept and wrong.

Thank You APA for all the you do!!!!
 
Congrats to the Pilots for having a backbone.

As for the TWU thanks for nothing AA probably overreached concerning the M&R group.

But as typical TWU, the only thing the membership got was a reach-a round with skydrol on their hands.
 
WHERE ARE ALL THE YES DRONES NOW? WHERE IS OVERSPEED, HIGHSPEED STEEL, RAPTOR BOY? THE JUDGE DENIED THE PILOTS? CODE SHARE AND FURLOGH PROTECTION? IS THAT RIGHT?

THAT THREAD "TULSA AMTS CAN MAKE IT BETTER" ? YES RIGHT ADMIT YOUR WRONG AND SIGN AN AMFA CARD!!!!
 
WHERE ARE ALL THE YES DRONES NOW? WHERE IS OVERSPEED, HIGHSPEED STEEL, RAPTOR BOY? THE JUDGE DENIED THE PILOTS? CODE SHARE AND FURLOGH PROTECTION? IS THAT RIGHT?

THAT THREAD "TULSA AMTS CAN MAKE IT BETTER" ? YES RIGHT ADMIT YOUR WRONG AND SIGN AN AMFA CARD!!!!

Exactly.. And don't forget Anomaly! Oh he is on another thread spouting about how much Industrial Unions are better than a craft Union!!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top