Ok, but, it does seem suspicious that both of you live in or near GPT(One in Ocean Springs, MS), registered within 20 minutes of each other, both went for the same sale at the same airline on the same route, and while BR found the $34 fares, he reportedly found the same $29 fares that Colin found.
Doing a little check in the white pages also shows that this Colin guy isn't located in MS. OK, but OTOH, his last name is there, in Ocean Springs to be exact. Population 18,000. What a coincidence!
BTW: Just confess. Getting out of denial is the first step.