So, minus your worthless legal opinion, it went pretty much as the USAPA email said. I don't see anyone getting slammed except for the west lawyers, who now have to reply to a stipulation from the court. Wow, a huge legal victory, AOL! If that's your idea of win, you may as well just make Marty a primary on your bank account.
Oh, and before you start accusing people of wasting money, remember it's your lawyers that keep filing the unripe cases. That's a real waste of cash for everyone.
By the way, this has already been adjudicated and AOL lost. USAPA is free to negotiate and present any list they choose. So says the Ninth Circuit and Judge Silver.
I am not sure who is more ignorant on the east. The lawyers for usapa, usapa the client or the RTB east pilots like you.
Wait for the transcripts to learn the truth.
Judge Lane asked usapa to drop their case and usapa refused. So he did it for them. Get your facts right. It was AMR and the UCC that asked for the stipulation. As much to restricy usapa as anything. To keep usapa from appealing or further interfering with the BK case. The creditors or AMR were not worried about the west. But they see they have a problem with usapa.
usapa has no standing in the BK court. usapa is not a creditor in the AMR BK. Take you worthless case and go away.
usapa won nothing from this case and now usapa is on the radar of the UCC, AMR and the APA. Read the letter exchange between Marty and Shamanski. Marty asked Shamanski to drop the case. Then he pointed out why legally usapa was going to lose. I guess you just can't help some people.
BTW is this "win" what usapa was looking for when they filed this case and spend 10's of thousand of dollars trying to stop the west and get the Arizona case transfered to NY? You do know that usapa asked judge Lane to transfer the case right? Lane denied that motion.
usapa's case was supposed to be the first to file, stop the west from filing our DFR case, and silence the west. Instead usapa now looks foolish, has proven they can't read and are really the only group causing problems.
Sure usapa can present any list they want. As long as they also present an LUP which usapa does not have. You also forget that usapa can present any list they want but that does not mean that anyone will accept or agree to it.
usapa lost in NY no way to spin that. usapa plans were shot down with the west not even having to file paperwork. A simple phone call explaining just how stupid and irrational usapa is and judge Lane understood. Where was the phone call from Shamanski to Marty? Professional, responsible lawyers would pick up the phone and ask a simple question if they did not understand something or thought there might be legal problems. Respectable lawyers don't file law suits first, receive a letter explaining why the law suit will fail yet continue to court and lose; all the while running up the bill knowing that the gravy train will soon end.
The days of usapa are numbered and so are the days of east pilots being in control and the ability to do stupid things.
PS. If the case in Arizona is not ripe why did usapa ask for that case to be moved to NY? Why not just tell the NY judge the case in Arizona is not ripe don't worry about it? Have you read the companies response?
