With all due respect to everyone who loves this idea and the uniform committee. This is not a good thing. Yea it feels great, it's liberating, it's cooler, everyone hates a tie on, but it looks terrible. Most of you agree the aviator shirt is NOT the shirt for this look. I'm disappointed that the uniform committee even considers this look to be appropriate and also with management. Last summer we saw many people that wore this relaxed look pretty nicely, but for the most part....the sloppy ones that looked bad with ties..always looked even sloppier without the tie. To top it off, America West still has a pinstriped uniform shirt out there that can be worn without the tie and it looks even worse, complete with yellow armpit stains.
For those people that take pride in their personal appearance (and you know who you are) they will wear this look ok. For the others....get ready, the top button only...doesn't happen. It's great to dream that people can take care of themselves, look clean, well groomed, pressed, but the reality is..those days are over. We need a uniform that is designed to be worn without the tie before we shed the ties.