USA320Pilot said:
I believe United is weaker than America West or Northwest. Furthermore, I would like to see US remain independent.
Right now I would not upset the code share apple cart durng a time when every penny counts.
IfUS Airways merges, I would rather see the company mege with Northwest then America West in that order because the combined business entity would be stronger than with United, unless the Chicago-based carrier can get its costs down further.
I'm not sure how you have arrived at your opinion, but here are the facts:
Airline / 4Q04 CASM / 4Q04 CASM ex-fuel
US / 10.96 / 8.79
NW / 11.36 / 8.87
UA / 10.68 / 8.34
HP / 7.98 / 6.00
WN / 7.59 / 6.22
B6 / 6.32 / 4.74
So, a merger with NW seems ludicrous since, at this point, NW (and YX due to their niche) is the only airline with
HIGHER CASM than US Airways. This would do nothing to advance the cause of US Airways becoming an LCC. (If you recall, when the 4Q results came out, I called US's removing itself from the highest CASM airline an accomplishment.)
HP, on the other hand, has competitive CASM and a better CASM-ex-fuel then WN. Of course, this is partly due to HP's longer stage-length, and I have seen Unisys score-cards which show that at the same stage length as HP's average stage legth, WN has a much better CASM number.
And of course, I can only assume that an HP-US merger would kill HP's decent CASM numbers.
So, I think a US-NW merger is a ludicrous proposition, based on CASM alone.
I think that a US-HP merger is intriquing. I can see why US wants it (what are the other options? Not good IMO). I am not sure why HP would want it, particularly including US' "warts and all". While HP is in a tight spot, it will probably find a way to squeek by... They've done that a lot lately. A merger with US would kill any ability to squeek by. However, if a third party decided, "hey, LCC's are the way to make money", I can see a third party acquiring both in order to instantly have an LCC as large as WN. However, this scenario would take a great deal of vision and even more cash... And I don't think there is enough of either to make such a merger successful.