As an ex-A330 Check Airman, I will tell you I would rather have more then less fuel. I can't tell you the number of times we came within just a few hundred pounds of having to divert to our alternate. Only the professionalism of the British Airways crews telling the final controller to let us (meaning US Airways) go ahead of them, allowed us to get to our intended destination.
Until you fly international, don't underestimate the value of more fuel regardless of what dispatch calculates.
CaptBud330, thanks from me as well. I haven't had that many crossings, but as a gear-yanker, it's good to know the PIC isn't ignoring his years of experience becaus the company is out to trip over the dollar to save the dime.
Our ClearDirect "friend" will probably give me another BLAH, BLAH, BLAH. That's what he does when he's got no logical reply. But here some numbers. I rounded off the exact amounts to protect one of the "Philly Eight." He got a letter from Corbusier and Yarko claiming he added about 2700# on about 40% of his flights. Let's say he was average for the "Evil Eight." That's an average of 164 gallons per leg. At $3/gal that's $490 per crossing IF they burned up all the gas, which they don't. If all 8 CAs averaged 8 legs a month (that's probably a little high) and burned an extra 164 gallons per leg, that would cost the company an extra $388,000 per year. But their not burning that much extra, only carrying it.
Here's why I think that $388,000 number is close, assuming it's all burned. The company says so. On one slide of the company's NON-FAA-approved 53-page Power Point Fuel Training course specially prepared for the "Philly Fuel Hogs," management crunched the numbers. The slide says it takes an extra 350 gallons of fuel per day to carry each extra 1000# for the entire A330 fleet. So if everyone is doing what the "Evil Eight" are doing, at $3/gal, it would cost the company $383,000 more a year. That's less than the cost of two diverts on a 330.
If you divide $383K by a $3 Billion fuel bill this year, that works out to less than 0.0012% of the total fuel bill.
A couple more things, since we now do this re-dispatch from International to Domestic, we don't need alternates with good WX. But I've held going into PHL-Rwy09 on CAVOK days. Every turn in holding on a light A-330 is about #1,000 fuel burn. I can see the company trying to save a dime, but their tripping over the dollar to get there and running up our blood pressure too. Snoop