- Joined
- May 8, 2007
- Messages
- 3,146
- Reaction score
- 3,236
U-SAPs will be unable to financially support itself, regardless of what its supporters might tell you.
The company will be loathe to dismiss 1/2 of it's pilots (100% of west plus a sizeable portion of the east with buyers remorse) en masse for dues delinquency, leaving the other 1/2 to pick up the slack through higher dues an assessments (and that doesn't even begin to cover the legal fees to fight the west). So while 1/2 of the pilots (who are wondering what they're getting for their money) are getting soaked, the joint negotiations will be at the same standstill. The west will never agree to a contract without Nicolau to the letter, and the east will never be able to open section 6 to get out from under LOA93.
So if you vote in U-SAPs you get an inexperienced, underfunded representitive that ends up costing more, but not delivering on any of its promises except that it got rid of ALPA. You lose all bargaining leverage because you are obviously disfunctional and overwhelmed by legal challenges and costs. The leadership failure will not attract talented volunteers. Those with experience want to be part of a winning team, and U-SAPs cannot provide that. Many volunteers do not want to be tarred with the U-SAPs label and will stay away and devote themselves to getting ALPA back on property, a task made easier by U-SAPs failures. The quick rush of victory will be quickly quelled as the reality of how far back the process to improve all US Airways pilots careers has been set.
If you vote for ALPA you get a well financed, experienced representitive that can deliver a contract that makes significant improvements in all pilots pay and benefits. ALPA is the most stable base from which to reach for these improvements. ALPA does not have an anti-US Airways east agenda, unlike U-SAPs transparent anti-west agenda. They have a duty to defend the arbitration process. It didn't go the east's way, but they can learn from this should they face arbitration in the future.
ALPA is far from perfect, but it's benefits far outweigh the potential liabilities inherent in U-SAPs. The AAA MEC is doing a grave disservice to its pilots by remaining silent on U-SAPs.
Before you vote, make sure the used car U-SAPs is selling you is worth the price. Ask hard questions and demand solid answers, not opinions or rhetoric. Determine for yourself if the quickest, surest way to improve your career lies with an underfunded, inexperienced union who is long on red-meat sound bites, and who relies almost exclusively on stoking the fears of a westie invasion, but woefully short on legitimate solutions.
OK. Lets be real here.
All the benefits and work you talk about COMES from the "sweat equity" of the pilots in their respective MECs and volunteers. And you imply that NONE or FEW, at least on the West and maybe a few on the East, will "quit" out of spite. Suit yourself but all that happens is you cut your nose off to spite you face. Again, it's really all about CHOICES now, isn't it?
The only thing ALPA really provides is some of your dues money back through "flight loss pay" and MOSTLY to administrative tasks, the rest of it going into the MCF. Besides, the MAIN reason for the large amounts of money in the MCF serves only one real purpose...STRIKE BENEFITS. So you tell me, with all that is going on right now, who is going to strike, at least at this company, in any case? If you want to address the issue of "underfunded" tell me? If funding IS important, what has all that "excess" cash that ALPA has in the MCF done for us up to this point? Remember, over 10 million per year of the dues money we already pay in, much of that is in the MCF and has NOT been returned to us.
As far as committee members and volunteers, do you think that USAPA is going to throw out all that valuable experience? That EXPERIENCE is OUR experience, not ALPA nationals! The overwhelming amount of volunteers and committee members doing work for US in ALPA will be doing the SAME JOBS in USAPA! Only two things are really changing...the representatives and the officer structure which will now be IN HOUSE. Our president WILL BE a US Airways pilot, as will all the officers and representatives. In FACT, I WOULD DEFINITELY NOT BE OPPOSED TO VOTING FOR SOMEONE LIKE MCILVENNA FOR PRESIDENT! How do you like THAT!
So, if the ONLY reason your voting for ALPA is "the list" and the only reason I'm voting USAPA is the CHOICE then we will just have to see. "THE list" or "THE CHOICE"? Which works better?
Here is the real difference between you and I. You see the "lesser of two evils". I see the "greater of two possibilities". You see them as ALPA and I see US as USAPA. You see the glass 1/3 empty. I see the glass 2/3rds FULL. You read ALPAs "Point of View". I live our 2/3rds "perspective". Isn't this REALLY where we're going with this?
As far as the DFR lawsuit issue that your talking about, again...more fear, uncertainty and doubt. I can tell you other unions have experienced the costs of major litigation regarding DFR and found them well within their budgetary capacity. With the size of our group the numbers show that won't be a problem. I can assure you that if you do a cursory "quick" crunch on the numbers you will find that 2/3 of the pilots paying dues is more than ample to handle both the management of the union, negotiating a contract and even...YES...a dreaded DFR lawsuit. Even if those pilots who sued the union WON, the ruling would not be for years and any money awarded, if any, would not be paid out until the appeals process is complete. And even then if you DO win damages, the union will be paying your dues money back to you or in the alternative, if it DID bankrupt the union (which it would'nt) who's going to protect your interests then? If ALPA, they wouldn't be back for YEARS at best.
So, back to earth. If you are not going to pay dues why don't you be the first to volunteer your service to help the others NOT PAY if USAPA gets in and let the chips fall. I can assure you that 1/3, one third...ONE THIRD of the pilots out West will square with this. One way or the other.
So what you REALLY are saying here is that ALPA pilots from OTHER airlines can represent us better than we can represent ourselves. Are we that lazy?
What are they doing that we are not ALREADY doing for ourselves? Remember, it's OUR guys running the MEC...not theirs!
Been around unions much?