Excerpt from PHL update today.
IMHO, this is the current and correct summary of the situation as it stands today.
"In the case before Judge Silver, the Addington Plaintiffs are claiming that USAPA had breached its duty to the West Pilots by failing to include the Nicolau list in the MOU. This, of course, is different than the previous DFR suit; the landscape in this case is entirely different in that there are multiple parties involved in the MOU that were not involved in the original case. In addition, the plaintiffs are seeking a separate seat for themselves in the McCaskill-Bond arbitration process with the APA.
As you know, this MOU was voted on and was considered neutral in respect to seniority. We were informed that we should not vote for or against the MOU based on seniority. This was made perfectly clear and the West pilots voted by a 97% margin to accept this MOU as written, with the clear understanding that the seniority issue would be decided through the McCaskill-Bond process should direct negotiations with the APA fail. From our perspective, to now insist that the Nicalou Award be included in the MOU is ludicrous. We can tell you we have confidence in our position and expect USAPA to prevail in Judge Sliver’s court. We will continue to keep you informed as the process unfolds."