Since I haven't seen you say that there aren't enough reserves to cover the open time, I assume reserve coverage is generally adequate. Yet you said:
Taken together, it sure sounds like the problem isn't not enough reserves, but managing the "pools" of reserves.
For example, I assume the West trips (just like the East) terminate at various times during the day. Why not put two or three AUTOs together so that it's beneficial for a reserve to drive to the airport to cover? Why tag (or call out) 2 or 3 reserves to cover those AUTOs? Sounds like it's just taking the easy way out.
Why not have enough HOT reserves to cover some of the AUTOs? Conversely, why approve AUTOs if there isn't enough HOT coverage? Again, it sounds like taking the easy course.
There is one thing most of you forget: all reserve in the West Garanteed 70 hrs, irrespective of their trip. Hence, when one is tagged for short trip, it is already paid within that 70 hrs. Hence, it is neither here or there if you go short or long trip. The only thing gives extra money, when there is an overninght ron. The scheduling tries to work everybody at least up to 70hrs. (since it is paid to each reserve/month)Any flying over that, I can see the long hauls are better, since it is extra $$$. Tagging is unpleasant, tiresome, incovenient but not a $$ issue.
Without knowing anything about the West contract, it sure sounds like scheduling is taking the easy way out - picking whoever they please to cover whatever they please. Tag, call at home, extend HOT. Makes life a lot easier on the schedulers, no thought or effort required. Sure seems like it plays havoc on the reserve F/A's though.
Jim