I have read this whole thread. Alot of points have been brought up that make sense, and alot doesn't. The fact the reserve system is what it is, can be brought back to the original contract language that DIDN'T provide a swing back to original language if other certain language is not implemented. IE if preferential bidding wasn't implemented within a certain time. The original bidding system would have swung back into effect. Its a way the union would be able to guarantee the company would hold there end of the bargin.
Having snap back language only protects what you negotiate. It is a shame the RES system is what it is. Once again the negtiators of past contracts didn't look far enough ahead to see how neglected negotiated items would effect it's membership.
I have also seen posts on here that basically stated "Senior" flight attendants seem they are entitled to the perks of years of service. I have to agree with that statement. If I have been working for a company for as long as I have, I too feel I should get what is coming to me. Granted I never worked under the present RES system, however, I was a reserve at one time also. People at my seniority who were original US before the PSA and PIA mergers had there pay remain stagnent while the other airlines where brought up to our pay scale, then obliterated by BK's. It is a matter of what is important to each of us that comes into play.
Negotiating a contract that is viable, approvable, and prosperous is the only way ALL flight attendants would feel comfortable with their working environment. The sad part is you would never be able to negotiate a contract pleasing everyone about everything. People in general will find fault in everything, all the time. It is human nature. Now, to the nitty gritty. Would I vote "FOR", a floating RES system....... Absolutely NO...... The whole premise of any contract is to provide protection for the system of "Date of Hire". If you in any way take away the strength of this agenda, you erode it's relivance. This is why in all contracts you award seniority with the perks of years of service (ie: pay, vacation, etc).
DOH is the foundation of all AFA's unionized contracts. Changing the RES system by making a BH'er fly floating RES is not the answer. Providing a solid foundation of contract language the company and union can agree to, is. The present system doen't work. Fact... Negotiate one that does... Better...
Just my opinion...