Oh Sorry... I confused the two.... I had VBR on the brain.... I guess only time will tell how this will all pan out. But I cant see APFA going for some deal where we lose jobs...
Maark, the APFA only looks at how senior the reserve list goes at DFW-D. (I heard it went to 25 years in December.) The VTF is intended to "reduce the number of people on reserve"--translated into the English, reduce the seniority of those on reserve. The problem is that the APFA does not tend to look one inch further than making the senior people at DFW happy.
We have reserves and availability people sitting around doing nothing because there are no open trips for them to fly. DFW-D reserves flew an average of 35 hours each last month, but got paid for 75 hours. If the few trips in Open Time go to senior people on the VTF list, there will be even less flying for those people on reserve/availability.
If the problem were only that the Reserve list is more senior because we are not hiring or recalling, this might be a solution. But, the main problem is not the seniority of the Reserve list, the problem is that the company is reducing flying and capacity and there is already nothing for the Reserves/availability people to fly. The only solution to that problem is either increase capacity/flying or reduce the total number of flight attendants--i.e., furlough. (Well, there are other options, such as buyouts to get senior people to retire, but we both know that is not going to happen at AA.)
APFA also has not thought through the fact that if more junior people are furloughed, then despite the VTF, the reserve list will go more senior once again because the formerly "more senior" are now "more junior"--there being no one beneath them on the active list.
I can't believe the APFA could say with a straight face that "this will be an opportunity for people on Reserve to earn money above their guarantees." No, they won't. The VTF list is populated by seniority with a limited number of people on the list each day in each base. What do you think the chances of someone making it onto that list who is also junior enough to be on reserve? Senior people are not dumb. They can see that most days there's almost nothing in Open Time. They can put themselves on the VTF list, collect 4 hours of flight pay, and never even have to take off their fuzzy bunny slippers.
P.S. Mike, the short furlough notice may have been provided by AA, but I also did not hear the APFA object on fairness grounds despite it's being legal and non-contractual. The APFA could have at least made public notice of the "coincidence" about the number of possible furloughs was 410. That was the maximum number the company could furlough and not have more than 249 LGA f/as on the list which would have caused the New York "Warn" law to kick in. It's why I am sure that more furloughs are to come.