Is there any way we can figure out the dollar amount of what we stand to lose/gain? What is the CIC worth? What is profit sharing worth? What is the two or three year extension worth. I think once we have an idea on that, we can judge what should be fair in return. Just my opinion though.
Negotiating off of industry standards is the key. Also, since the network of solidarity forced Hemenway to throw down another card on the table for all to see, you use that knowledge of what he said was affordable raises and benefit enhancements for mechanics and you use that as the bare minimum. Now, fair has a raised bar. We need pension enhancements, better scope, shift differ, wage increases with at least the same future wage increases as Hemenway found affordable to our mechanics, extra extra. Other airline workers get it, and now our mechanics do also. Ramp rats expect it to and our network of solidarity will demand and accept no less.
Bottom line is the company won't sign on without getting PS, CIC, extension of term. The CIC is significant so I understand your concern. It's worth $21.43 and up to $26 in a couple years. But it only applies to the east. IMO, if a fair deal is doable then the CIC should be given up in order to get all into one contract and to spread the contract enhancements over more benefits as opposed to just wage alone. Nonetheless, $20 is minimum with 3% raises over the next 5 years, not 2%. Hemenway is also bent on getting those 19 stations since Canale has appeased him before.
I'm not convinced we need to give 19 stations up. Does the company have customer service workers in those stations? I also think the company has customer service workers in many east stations but has the ramp contracted out. I think ramp rats should also be at those stations and instead of negotiating on Hemenway's terms of losing stations, we should rather be negotiating on terms to bring back fleet service at the contracted out stations where the company has been affording other work groups to continue working at. Any station that has our own customer service workers should also have ramp workers. Are they better than ramp rats? Of course not.
My position is that we keep all stations that we have and we ask for more stations instead of negotiating off of Hemenway's model. I'm miffed at why our own negotiators didn't propose a scope enhancement and ask for more stations as opposed to putting out a proposal that contracts out another 1/3 of our stations. WTF? I thought all unions ask for more scope when negotiating outside of bankruptcy? I would have met Hemenway's request for less stations with a proposal to get fleet service in the outsourced stations where Hemenway has been affording company customer service workers. How many east stations do we have customer service but no ramp rats? Why is that?
At the absolute minimum, grandfather rights offering full contract protections with no 'drop dead' date, to the human beings that work in those 19 stations should be agreed to.
regards,
Tim Nelson
IAM Local Chairman, 1487, Chicago