I hope we don't have to wait this long..
Slow civil process unfair to business
Wichita Business Journal
Date: Sunday, June 22, 1997, 11:00pm CDT
Sometime in the next two weeks, U.S. District Court Judge Sam Crow is expected to issue a key ruling in the now 12-year-old litigation entitled "William I. Koch versus Koch Industries." As reported by Roz Hutchinson last week, the ruling involves a 3-year-old petition from Koch Industries for summary judgment that, if granted, could halt Bill Koch's latest series of claims against Charles Koch and his twin brother David.
However, if Judge Crow rules against any piece of the litigation, the latest Koch vs. Koch lawsuit likely would be set for trial sometime next year -- more than 13 years since the lawsuit was first filed.No matter what opinions have been formed on the case, it should be troubling that this litigation has been ongoing for 12 years without a substantial ruling on the facts.
How can this happen? Is one side in the dispute abusing the legal system? Is the federal system that overloaded? Consider what has happened since Bill Koch filed this latest lawsuit against his brothers. In 1985, John Carlin was governor of Kansas, Ronald Reagan was president, Oliver North was an obscure Marine toiling in a windowless basement office in the Old Executive Office Building, the Kansas City Royals were playing championship baseball and the class of 1997 was entering first grade.It is incomprehensible that any lawsuit could be so complicated as to take half a generation to get its first significant ruling on the facts of the case.
For years, businesses have complained that the nation is in need of major tort reform. Koch vs. Koch should only add fuel to that argument. Even our court system should have time limits on cases.