I'm not quite getting your point here though I do feel the angst of boarding.
(
but I myself point to the FAs who sometimes turn invisible during this process -- but some do indeed keep an eye open for this sort of behavior -- kudos to you folks
) . But I suspect that bad behavior goes all the way back to cavemen and not just to the airplane cabin.
I'm gold so we get on and get settled without too much problem though
sometimes you must move up a bin. So even if it's a full flight with lots of preferreds, it seems to me that most preferred folks should and do make out well with boarding. I do agree that the boarding process grows increasingly restive now that more folks bring more bags into the cabin. I tend to be a little more assertive about my place in the queue simply because I intend to defend my boarding perk since everything else has gone out the door and I'm in no mood for queue jumpers anymore.
In my book, once you get past zone 1 and zone 2, it might indeed be useful for the GAs to eyeball those folks traveling like loaded-down refugees
and tell them to check their bag at the cabin door. Hey, the airline already made its money from those who paid the bag fee,
and it's worth the effort to relieve a few more pax of their bags at the door to hasten the boarding process, ease cabin congestion, and take off on time. It'll improve your DOT rankings and maybe earn those bonuses again, and those folks who check their bag know that the bag makes the flight as it's pretty difficult to mess this process up at this stage of the game. It's innovative, minimally interventional, and what an airline that sees the big picture would do to connect the aviation dots.
Barry