Al,
If a snapshot were taken today, it would hightlight exactly why the Nic is fair and equitable. The problem you are having seeing it, is because you are still looking at it as though there are still two seperate companies, and that the east pilots are making gains on something that is theirs. Not true. The reason there is even any east attrition is a result of "the merger". I suppose same could be said of the West attrition. The reason there are any east coast markets is "because of the merger". The reason PHX is no longer profitable for the West is because of saddling the east higher cost on the West operation..i.e. "because of the merger".
So, we throw all the cost and gains into a one pile, and share them equitably, that is what Nic does. What you are suggesting is that we throw all the cost onto the West, put all the upside on the east, then take a snapshot, after east pilots have already stolen attrition that no longer even belongs to them "because of the merger", and have a redo today for an event that took place 6 years ago.
Everything Parker, Kirby, Isom, Nicolau, Wake, Bybee, Tashima, Graber, Silver, Lakefield, have said to date upholds my point of view. The east pilots have reaped a huge benefit from the merger at the West's pilots expense. The fact that West pilots are furloughed while east furloughed pilots have been employed since the merger makes me sick to my stomach, I don't care if Colello had 17 years or not, he stole Odell's job.
In the simplest terms, the West's expectation is that a final and binding seniority award will be honored. The West, nor the east, would have never entered into arbitration with the expectation that the award could simply be dismissed by popular vote.
The West has given up on the expectation that any player in this fiasco would actually have any integrity and honor their word. And, I am not just talking about the east pilots. The company has lied to the West from the get go, and they turn up the volume of the lies with every passing month. First it was, "no employed personel will be replaced with furloughees", then it was "third list???? what third list?", then "yeah. we ACCEPTED the list, but define ACCEPTED". Now it is just emboldened straight up lies that are the result of 6 years of lying to everybody about the situation in the first place.
Enjoy your fathers day, and try to remember the furloughed West guys who lost their jobs to benefit the employed East pilots.