Worse?
It is all relative. The Left column will get better and the Right column will stay the same. ( The Right will only be worse in a
relative sense as the Left gets better). I think we should be cleardirect about it.
The DOH on the Left column will continue to be more junior with each passing bid, eventually matching the DOH on the Right column because the Right will remain virtually stagnant, according to Doug.
As time passes, the DOH of both sides will be become virtually equal because separate ops forces favorable attrition, new wide bodies, and hiring, on the Left, vs. stagnation on the Right.
The DOH will become
equal but the value of the respective positions will remain just as
unequal as they are today. No one on the Left would be willing to swap positions with those on the Right now, and that won't change with time.
The Left holds to its current opinion and gets positive gains. The Right holds to its opinion and hopes to someday get a court to award damages, over an internal union dispute, in which they refuse to discuss for a resolution.
The Risk is all on the RIght, and it increases rapidly from here on out.
Caveats: The West is free to adjust the positions on the Right if they want to add clarity, especially if the want to add info on junior line holder DOH. The info is from the 2011 West seniority list and may be slightly different today. Additionally, the effects of a Nic bid would be slightly less dramatic than the current bids that are completed only with pilots in the Left column, rather than all USAPA pilots.