B.s. On both. Profit sharing was changed company wide . Pay raises are in line with what PILOT raises are ...not doctors or lawyer or scientist or FA's or ACS. No openers have been presented on contract 2015 so stop with YOUR miss information. Your just an outsider .you must be envious or something.700UW said:Why did ALPA get DL Pilots a 20% raise in the past 2 1/2 years and everyone else got 4%-8% in the same time frame?
Why is DALPA asking for a 35% raise and the elimination of Profit Sharing?
What happened to ACS and FAs Profit sharing when DALPA agreed to a 33% reduction?
Who is working in tandem?Kev3188 said:It's nice watching you guys working in tandem.
Meto-- since you contend that the IAM is "not an FA Union," who would you suggest?
Last time we heard the chorus of "anyone but AFA." Well, the crowd got what it asked for.
That was tried before, and didn't end well. There's no real interest in repeating that, but just for fun, let's say there is; why do you think it would be better/different is time around?metopower said:Maybe an in house .
It would function like DALPA and the dispatchers union. By being in house perhaps it would use the same tactics and relationships that have served our groups so well. In house union failed not at DL but NW . Much different even though you don't see it.Kev3188 said:That was tried before, and didn't end well. There's no real interest in repeating that, but just for fun, let's say there is; why do you think it would be better/different is time around?
They are as much as DALPA is .Kev3188 said:We're all the same group now.
Why do you assume the same "tactics & relationships" that have worked so well for other groups on the property won't for the FAs?
PAFCA isn't in-house.
I always find it funny when this happens.metopower said:B.s. On both. Profit sharing was changed company wide . Pay raises are in line with what PILOT raises are ...not doctors or lawyer or scientist or FA's or ACS. No openers have been presented on contract 2015 so stop with YOUR miss information. Your just an outsider .you must be envious or something.
I honestly believe any union, even the IAM(which i dislike), can act that way.metopower said:It would function like DALPA and the dispatchers union. By being in house perhaps it would use the same tactics and relationships that have served our groups so well. In house union failed not at DL but NW . Much different even though you don't see it.
wait what? whos pilots are worse off than the FAs? no pilot at Delta thats for sure.WorldTraveler said:who don't you repeat that same exercise for pilots and find out that they are worse off than FAs and, wait, wait, they have a union.
Unions can't force higher salaries than what the market delivers.
and as much as you would like to argue otherwise, DL is PULLING up the FAs. you do recall Laura Glading's comment that she has been chasing DL FA salaries her entire career... and she still is chasing DL total compensation considering that DL FAs blasted way past AA FAs new contract when DL FAs got 16.5% in profit sharing AND DL spent more per FA on benefits than did AA.
so much for what a union can do.
or they used dues from other carriers....WorldTraveler said:sorry but the link didn't work.
but I don't need to see the document.
Either ALPA didn't spend that much in the same time period or they saved up multiple years worth of dues in order to pay for the negotiating sessions or they would be broke.
btw, $1.2 million divided by 10K DL pilots comes out to $120 per pilot. I am sure that meto would be happy if all he had to pay for ALPA's negotiating services was $120. He may or may not tell us what he pays in annual ALPA dues but I can assure you it is WELL beyond that amount....
and that highlights just how much unions collect that go beyond just negotiating a contract.
and to think that is only an D/ALPA thing is ridiculous.
DL FAs will pay way more than $14M in services from the IAM.
and your statistic does highlight yet another statistic - if the pilots can negotiate a contract for $3 million, why do DL FAs need to pay easily $10 million more in union dues than what it took BLOATED ALPA to negotiate a contract for the pilots?
its a b*tch under the RLA. yet another reason why the RLA needs changes......southwind said:Sooooo.....the question is then, "IF" the IAM is voted in and cannot get an acceptable contract to be ratified, can the FA's kick the IAM to the curb?
My guess is it would be some loooooong drawn out process , once they're imbedded like a tick!
I liked the plane but got damn did it have its problems. I think UPS and FedEx have a lot of them worked out......of course it helps that they don't have a PAX cabin or are expected to fly LAX-HKG non-stop.....WorldTraveler said:yep... your list should be the same as mine. apparently I counted too many blocks I passed instead of aircraft models. I forgot the M11 and D10.
How could I forget the flowing toilet river down the aisle M11 LAX-FRA diversion and cxl.
wait... I didn't work that flight from a desk in ATL.... contrary to what someone(s) think.
Yeah right.metopower said:You asked the wrong question. What has a national union gained by having DALPA as part of them. THEY answer to DALPA not the other way around like your iam.DALPA leaves tomarrow alpa collapses.
metopower said:I always find it funny when this happens.
But just cause you are a pilot doesn't mean you should get 8% when we got 5%.
You guys are really important, don't get me wrong, but that plane doesn't fly with out me fixing it, Baba working it as a FA and Kev throwing the bags on it.
I would argue that any mechanic is just as important as a pilot. One screw in the wrong place and that plane if a flaming hole in the ground. Doesn't make a damn if God him self is the pilot on that bad boy......
............ Well don't read into anything that I wrote that I didn't t say. First I NEVER equated how important my job was to any other job. I guess you must. Second I have many more friends that are working in acs an FA's then in the pilot group. Remember I'm WESTERN and some feelings never go away. What I said was I should get payed what other PILOTS get payed not doctors or CEO 's or mechanics. If you get a raise of 40% then good for you. If that is what other mechanism are getting. Then I just went to the wrong school."............
I honestly believe any union, even the IAM(which i dislike), can act that way.
Its all about who you elect and making sure you have good by-laws.
I don't see any work group at Delta voting in a union and it not being like Delta and DALPA. JMO.
wait what? whos pilots are worse off than the FAs? no pilot at Delta thats for sure.
or they used dues from other carriers....
but chances are they save up dues outside of negos.
its a b*tch under the RLA. yet another reason why the RLA needs changes......
I liked the plane but got damn did it have its problems. I think UPS and FedEx have a lot of them worked out......of course it helps that they don't have a PAX cabin or are expected to fly LAX-HKG non-stop.....
Yeah right.
IMO DALPA isn't nearly as important to ALPA as the pilot think.
...........Better check which group pays more dues money to ALPA. Then make that statement........
but if DALPA calls the shots then how did your union negotiate that part about 35% of all new hires must come from ALPA carriers?
..........I don't know where you got that. No agreement about that other then the hold over from NW that we are stuck with. DL pilots wouldn't make an agreement for Comair and DL owned them. Now your talking AA or UA that is different . I'm in DALPA but I guess you can't tell that I feel a difference........
Is your union wasting time and money for ALPA or (the more likely case) did Lee and the national union have that little baby put in there (and it probably cost you an extra % or two in pay FWIW)
topDawg said:I always find it funny when this happens.
But just cause you are a pilot doesn't mean you should get 8% when we got 5%.
...read above.......
You guys are really important, don't get me wrong, but that plane doesn't fly with out me fixing it, Baba working it as a FA and Kev throwing the bags on it.
I would argue that any mechanic is just as important as a pilot. One screw in the wrong place and that plane if a flaming hole in the ground. Doesn't make a damn if God him self is the pilot on that bad boy......
Well don't read into anything that I wrote that I didn't t say.
......... First I NEVER equated how important my job was to any other job. I guess you must. Second I have many more friends that are working in acs an FA's then in the pilot group. Remember I'm WESTERN and some feelings never go away. ..........
I honestly believe any union, even the IAM(which i dislike), can act that way.
Its all about who you elect and making sure you have good by-laws.
I don't see any work group at Delta voting in a union and it not being like Delta and DALPA. JMO.
wait what? whos pilots are worse off than the FAs? no pilot at Delta thats for sure.
or they used dues from other carriers....
but chances are they save up dues outside of negos.
its a b*tch under the RLA. yet another reason why the RLA needs changes......
I liked the plane but got damn did it have its problems. I think UPS and FedEx have a lot of them worked out......of course it helps that they don't have a PAX cabin or are expected to fly LAX-HKG non-stop.....
Yeah right.
IMO DALPA isn't nearly as important to ALPA as the pilot think.
........ Better check which group pays more dues money to ALPA. Then make that statement......
but if DALPA calls the shots then how did your union negotiate that part about 35% of all new hires must come from ALPA carriers?
........I don't know where you got that. No agreement about that other then the hold over from NW that we are stuck with. DL pilots wouldn't make an agreement for Comair and DL owned them. Now your talking AA or UA that is different . I'm in DALPA but I guess you can't tell that I feel a difference.......
Is your union wasting time and money for ALPA or (the more likely case) did Lee and the national union have that little baby put in there (and it probably cost you an extra % or two in pay FWIW)
......damn good question.....
metopower said:
I always find it funny when this happens.
But just cause you are a pilot doesn't mean you should get 8% when we got 5%.
You guys are really important, don't get me wrong, but that plane doesn't fly with out me fixing it, Baba working it as a FA and Kev throwing the bags on it.
I would argue that any mechanic is just as important as a pilot. One screw in the wrong place and that plane if a flaming hole in the ground. Doesn't make a damn if God him self is the pilot on that bad boy......
............ Well don't read into anything that I wrote that I didn't t say. First I NEVER equated how important my job was to any other job. I guess you must. Second I have many more friends that are working in acs an FA's then in the pilot group. Remember I'm WESTERN and some feelings never go away. What I said was I should get payed what other PILOTS get payed not doctors or CEO 's or mechanics. If you get a raise of 40% then good for you. If that is what other mechanism are getting. Then I just went to the wrong school."............
I honestly believe any union, even the IAM(which i dislike), can act that way.
Its all about who you elect and making sure you have good by-laws.
I don't see any work group at Delta voting in a union and it not being like Delta and DALPA. JMO.
wait what? whos pilots are worse off than the FAs? no pilot at Delta thats for sure.
or they used dues from other carriers....
but chances are they save up dues outside of negos.
its a b*tch under the RLA. yet another reason why the RLA needs changes......
I liked the plane but got damn did it have its problems. I think UPS and FedEx have a lot of them worked out......of course it helps that they don't have a PAX cabin or are expected to fly LAX-HKG non-stop.....
Yeah right.
IMO DALPA isn't nearly as important to ALPA as the pilot think.
...........Better check which group pays more dues money to ALPA. Then make that statement........
but if DALPA calls the shots then how did your union negotiate that part about 35% of all new hires must come from ALPA carriers?
..........I don't know where you got that. No agreement about that other then the hold over from NW that we are stuck with. DL pilots wouldn't make an agreement for Comair and DL owned them. Now your talking AA or UA that is different . I'm in DALPA but I guess you can't tell that I feel a difference........
Is your union wasting time and money for ALPA or (the more likely case) did Lee and the national union have that little baby put in there (and it probably cost you an extra % or two in pay FWIW)
topDawg said:I always find it funny when this happens.
But just cause you are a pilot doesn't mean you should get 8% when we got 5%.
...read above.......
You guys are really important, don't get me wrong, but that plane doesn't fly with out me fixing it, Baba working it as a FA and Kev throwing the bags on it.
I would argue that any mechanic is just as important as a pilot. One screw in the wrong place and that plane if a flaming hole in the ground. Doesn't make a damn if God him self is the pilot on that bad boy......
Well don't read into anything that I wrote that I didn't t say.
......... First I NEVER equated how important my job was to any other job. I guess you must. Second I have many more friends that are working in acs an FA's then in the pilot group. Remember I'm WESTERN and some feelings never go away. ..........
I honestly believe any union, even the IAM(which i dislike), can act that way.
Its all about who you elect and making sure you have good by-laws.
I don't see any work group at Delta voting in a union and it not being like Delta and DALPA. JMO.
wait what? whos pilots are worse off than the FAs? no pilot at Delta thats for sure.
or they used dues from other carriers....
but chances are they save up dues outside of negos.
its a b*tch under the RLA. yet another reason why the RLA needs changes......
I liked the plane but got damn did it have its problems. I think UPS and FedEx have a lot of them worked out......of course it helps that they don't have a PAX cabin or are expected to fly LAX-HKG non-stop.....
Yeah right.
IMO DALPA isn't nearly as important to ALPA as the pilot think.
........ Better check which group pays more dues money to ALPA. Then make that statement......
but if DALPA calls the shots then how did your union negotiate that part about 35% of all new hires must come from ALPA carriers?
........I don't know where you got that. No agreement about that other then the hold over from NW that we are stuck with. DL pilots wouldn't make an agreement for Comair and DL owned them. Now your talking AA or UA that is different . I'm in DALPA but I guess you can't tell that I feel a difference.......
Is your union wasting time and money for ALPA or (the more likely case) did Lee and the national union have that little baby put in there (and it probably cost you an extra % or two in pay FWIW)
......damn good question.....