Phoenix
Veteran
- Joined
- Apr 16, 2003
- Messages
- 8,584
- Reaction score
- 7,430
... 1.No I am arguing that we reached the Nic through arbitration. 2. Internal, binding does not matter.
Wrong on both points.
1. It isn't the "we" that matters to the 9th. It is the unions that have the authority and responsibility. It was ALPA alone that ruled the ALPA internal process and it was ALPA alone that had the legal authority. ALPA had the Nic as a proposal and the 9th said as much. It is abundantly obvious that the 9th fully acknowledges that USAPA has sole authority and responsibility now.
2. all three judges disagree with your second point, unless of course you think the judges are incompetent wannabees that don't know the impact of their words, and coincidentally used opposing adjectives consistently throughout their majority opinion and dissent. I know.. I know... its the only bet you have. Pull out your wallet and persuade everyone into double or nothing.
Cheers. 🙄