Nobody out East seemed to have any heart burn with ALPA merger policy while they were being fed the party line of obvious success by their East reps. Once you didn't get what you thought you were entitled to (DOH), then obviously the whole process was flawed from the onset. Please spare us the sob story and the violins. Had Nic determined un-fenced DOH was in fact, the gold standard, you guys would have been carrying Prater around Herdon on your shoulders and furloughed pilots would have been house hunting in PHX. 🙄
Having been around these boards since 2001, I can say with certainty that with some there was no love lost when it came to ALPA. This was especially true during BK1, less so with BK2.
There was a significant number of pilots who wanted out of ALPA at almost any cost. Whether this almost blind hatred of ALPA colored their views to the point where the situation rests now I couldn't hazard a guess.
IIRC there were several attempts to oust ALPA prior & during BK1. The efforts failed up until the Nic award which apparently galvanized a majority to rid themselves of ALPA at any cost.
Wise choice? No idea! What i do know is everyone is paying a very steep price in hard dollar and emotional terms. There is a way out, I just don't know what it is as I don't know nearly enough about the QOL issues and Seniority in general as it applies to pilots.
On one hand DOH seems like a quick and easy way to integrate the 2 groups. I get hired on Monday and you get hired on Tuesday, I'm ahead of you. Period.
Not picking sides here but what I've read on Nic makes it seem flawed, It appears to pick winners and losers.
I just don't like to see good people screwed at work and right now EVERYONE of you is screwed! My God there are prostitutes that have been screwed less.
IMO there is a way out. There's always a way out and the problem now is one of testosterone poisoning. Everyone is bellowing and posturing and so far all that's happened is a few lawyers are a bit richer for their efforts. This is like the trench warfare of WWI, Both sides dug into fixed positions with precious little ground gained by either side.
This situation calls for bold vision and leadership, not kingdom building and Machiavellian intrigue and I'll bet that the posters here know exactly where the common ground is. Problem is that those at the top in USAPA have their own personal agendas and as a result 5,000 or so pilot careers hang in the balance. It's not right.