First of all your not an IAM member and dont have a clue what transpired.
First of all the IAM CBA where all heavy maintenance was abrogated in court, but the judge held the ruling in abeyance, meaning if the membership ratfied the final offer the ruling wouldnt take effect. The final offer wasnt a negotiated and agreed upon tentative agreement it was a final offer.
In the final offer the company was free to outsource anything they wanted as long as they kept CLT and PIT heavy mtc open, the company outsourced the 757s, 767s and A330, the 737s and airbus narrowbodies were still done in-house.
Upon the merger the IAM negotiated the 50% billable hours must be done in-house. The 401k arbitration was won, and the match was negotiated away in the transition agreement in lieu of getting the IAMNPF which is a defined benefit plan that the company paid for and not the employee. As you know our DBP was terminated in chapter 11 which forced the membership to fund their own retirement.
Once again the attendance control arbitration was not negotiated away, our cba was abrogated, the ruling was held in abeyance, the company gave us a final offer which the judge made us vote on, the letter was removed in the final offer, the final offer was not a negotiated and agreed upon offer, it was a final offer.
Once again, learn the facts, I was on the Negotiating Committee, were you?
Your not even an IAM Member, so why do you post things that didnt occur?
What I just posted are the facts, so dont let them get in your way.
And you are comparing and confusing an arbitration over contract language between a company and a union, not an internal union arbitration which was between ALPA at HP and ALPA at US.