There's little doubt that there is more to this story than what USAPA claims. I prefer to wait to see what other facts come out before I make any claims as to who is or isn't right in this situation. However, based on reputation, I would absolutely doubt that anyone in Management would knowingly or intentionally order a flight crew to fly an aircraft that was known to have a genuine mechanical/electrical issue. No one, and I mean no one wants to have an incident or accident because of scheduling demands or meeting DOT performance metrics. If someone in Management tried to pull such a thing they would be walked out the door immediately and I suspect Captain Paul Morell would be first in line to see that such a fool got the boot he/she deserved.
On the other hand, I wouldn't trust USAPA or one of their lanyard-wearing zealots to tell the truth if their life depended on it. Was there an issue? Maybe, maybe not but you certainly cannot ascertain that information based on taking an east pilot or Mike Cleary at his/her word. We all know how poorly USAPA/east pilots have kept their word over the past five years. You know the saying - once a liar, always a liar. Furthermore, I wouldn't at all put intentional sabotage past USAPA and their unscrupulous behavior.
Cleary want's DOH and nobody is listening to him. Cleary wants to make safety a negotiating ploy and nobody is listening to him. Cleary wants to destroy the west pilots and nobody is listening to him. Cleary wants a VP fired and nobody listening to him. So, what's a narcissistic sociopath who wants his way and all the attention he can get supposed to do when nobody is listening to him? Well, create your own crisis and then blame it on your enemy. Isn't that what Dateline NBC did when they wanted to do a story about pickup trucks that explode? Can't get it to work without intervention so you setup explosives for the camera and then lie to the everyone about what really happened.
Anyway, I suspect that is at least as plausible as anything Cleary said in his stupid USA Today ad.