Don't you have two working for the union right now?
You guys seem to like them because you keep reelecting them.
I believe you are referring to the Freedom mess post 9/11 correct?
That situation is not as clear as people want to believe. I do not know the specifics of the 2 you are talking about. But I do know a F/O that appears on the "Freedom List" or whatever it is called.
Back when this thing came up and he was offered a position with Freedom he called and then wrote to ALPA concerning this subject. the response letter he received from ALPA he still has. I do not remember the exact statement, however suffice it to say that ALPA National stated in the letter that he would not be violating any agreements or crossing any type of line by accepting the position.
It was not until he was almost done with training that the position changed from ALPA national. So in his case and others like him who were furloughed, they ended up on a list that was not a list when they started.
If anybody still has access to the ALPA boards this was a hot topic. Would be interesting to see if those threads are still in the archives. This topic I believe was one of the issues that eventually ended with ALPA removing the furloughed pilots from the ALPA boards. At the time it appeared that they wanted do a bit of revisionist history and the furloughed guys got in the way, along with some other topics the furloughed were very vocal about. Back then the order of the day at ALPA seemed to be "If we don't like what they have to say, don't let them say it."
I think how ALPA treated the furloughed guys on this issue and others directly led to ALPA getting voted off the property. The cast off masses that ALPA had no time for back then, were back on the property in time to provide the required votes to remove ALPA.
If I remember correct one of our esteemed self appointed guru posters here who we all know, was all over the ALPA boards at the time leading the charge to have the furloughed guys removed from the boards.
I don't care what people have to say, and I always encourage people to speak what they feel no matter if I agree with it or not. But what I saw happening on the ALPA boards back then and the censorship disgusted me.